Accidental ArtMaker, a vibrant brand catering to women rediscovering their love for art, approached us with a challenge: to increase engagement, build stronger relationships with their audience, and increase sales during the competitive holiday season. Over two months, we worked together to achieve remarkable results, including a 40% year-over-year increase in holiday revenue, with sales climbing from $18,000 to $35,000. Here’s how we did it.

Understanding the Audience — The Heart Of Our Strategy 

At the core of our strategy was a deep dive into Accidental Art Maker’s audience. We wanted to go beyond demographic data to truly understand their motivations, behaviors, and preferences.

We discovered that most of the brand’s customers were women in midlife, rekindling a long-lost passion for art. Their connection to the brand wasn’t transactional—it was emotional. They didn’t just want to buy art supplies or decorative pieces; they wanted to feel inspired, appreciated, and part of a creative community.

With this insight, we segmented the audience based on purchasing behavior, email engagement, and personal interests. This segmentation allowed us to tailor content that felt personal and relevant, making each email feel like a conversation rather than a marketing push.

 

Crafting Dreamy + Conversational Copy

Our copy was never just about selling—it was about storytelling. Every email was carefully written to resonate with Accidental Art Maker’s audience, blending inspiration with a touch of whimsy.

We leaned into a dreamy, conversational tone that mirrored the brand’s ethos. Emails spoke about the joy of creating, the magic of rediscovery, and the beauty of imperfection in art.

For example, instead of saying, “Buy this holiday art piece now!” we wrote, “Imagine this exquisite art piece on your mantel, bringing a touch of holiday magic into your home.”

 

This approach nurtured trust and connection. By focusing on building relationships rather than pushing products, we created a loyal audience that was more receptive when it came time to sell during the Black Friday and Cyber Monday (BFCM) period.

 

It all came directly from Sharon herself, the brand’s owner. 

One of the unique aspects of our strategy was ensuring that every email felt like it was coming directly from Sharon, the brand’s owner and the heart of Accidental Art Maker. Sharon herself was on a deeply personal journey of rediscovering her love for art, which made her the perfect storyteller for her audience. 

 

Our emails were infused with her genuine passion and authenticity, making them relatable and heartfelt. At times, we even shared real-life scenarios from Sharon’s journey—whether it was her excitement over completing a new piece or her reflections on finding time for creativity amidst a busy schedule. We also shared her art’s images in the emails to make it more relatable and real. 

 

These personal touches added a layer of realism and intimacy that resonated deeply with readers, bridging the gap between brand and audience. Sharon’s voice wasn’t just selling art; it was inspiring a shared journey, making every recipient feel like they were part of a supportive, creative community.

 

Visually Appealing Designs —Art in every email

Our email designs played a pivotal role in bringing the newsletters to life. Each email had a unique theme that tied the copy and visuals together seamlessly.

For instance:

• One email celebrating the changing seasons featured a palette of warm autumn tones, delicate leaf motifs, and inspiring quotes about creativity.
• A holiday-themed email sparkled with festive colors and intricate design elements that felt as artistic as the products being sold.

The goal was to make every email feel like a piece of art itself—something recipients would look forward to opening. These visually captivating designs elevated the brand’s image and reinforced the connection with its audience.

                                                     

Metrics that Proved our Strategy Worked

The results speak for themselves:

Average open rates increased from 25% to 35%. This 10% jump showed that our catchy subject lines and personalized approach were grabbing attention.

Average click rates rose from 1% to 1.56%, demonstrating that recipients were not only opening emails but also engaging with the content.

Holiday revenue skyrocketed from $18,000 last year to $35,000 this year—a testament to the strength of our email strategy.

 

Power of Personalization + Segmentation

Our segmentation strategy ensured that the right message reached the right audience. For example:

• High spenders received exclusive previews of limited-edition holiday products, making them feel valued.
• New customers were welcomed with a series of emails that gently introduced them to the brand’s story, fostering a sense of belonging.
• Dormant subscribers were re-engaged with inspiring content, reminding them of the joy of art and inviting them to rediscover it.
• Potential customers who added to carts but didn’t place an order were reminded of taking that next step in their art discovery journey. 

This level of personalization was about making each recipient feel seen and appreciated. The purpose was to become a part of their journey where the Accidental Art Maker played a small role in amping up their experience and making it memorable.

 

BFCM: Turning storytelling into sales

When the BFCM period arrived, we repurposed our dreamy, conversational language to subtly nudge readers toward making a purchase.

Instead of hard-selling, we used phrases like:

• “This is your sign to treat yourself to a little holiday creativity.”
• “Add a touch of magic to your holiday decor with our limited-edition art pieces.”

This approach, combined with the trust we had built through months of relationship-focused content, resulted in a surge of holiday sales.

 

Subject lines that Sparked Curiosity

Our subject lines were designed to intrigue and delight, standing out in crowded inboxes. 

 

Some examples include:

• “Just take a deep breath, (first name).”

• • “Unwrap a little holiday magic (it’s waiting for you!)”

• “Make every moment count, (first name)”

• “Forget it all for once, (first name).”

 

By balancing creativity with relevance, these subject lines drove higher open rates and set the tone for engaging email experiences.

 

Lessons learned 

The success of this campaign reaffirmed a few key principles that reap results in the long run. 

 

Know your audience deeply. The more you understand their desires and challenges, the better you can connect with them. Not all customers want the same thing. 

 

Focus on relationships, not just sales. Building trust and emotional resonance creates a loyal audience that supports your brand in the long run. 

 

Design matters. Beautiful, cohesive visuals can transform your messaging and leave a lasting impression. Visual impact is always stronger than just words. 

 

Data is your ally. By tracking metrics and behaviors, you can continuously refine your strategy for even better results. Data should always lead your path. 

 

Looking ahead, we plan to build on this momentum by introducing more dynamic segmentation, experimenting with interactive email content, and exploring new ways to surprise and delight the audience.

 

Final thoughts

At its heart, this campaign was about more than just selling art—it was about celebrating creativity and connection. By staying true to Accidental Art Maker’s brand values and putting the audience first, we were able to achieve extraordinary results.

 

If you’re looking to transform your email marketing and build meaningful relationships with your audience, let’s talk. Together, we can create something just as impactful.

 

Sign up to our newsletter to stay updated with all the magic email marketing has to offer.