Overview

Deliverability is the silent killer of email revenue.
Most Shopify and DTC brands obsess over design, offers, segmentation, or pop-ups —
but if your emails are not landing in the primary inbox, none of it matters.

In late 2024 and early 2025, one of our DTC clients (a well-known multi-location CPG retailer) came to us with a familiar problem:

• Their paid ads were volatile

• Revenue was inconsistent

• Their email revenue was far below potential

• Inbox placement was declining

• Their previous agency had ignored deliverability hygiene

Within 30 days, Retain Marketing rebuilt their lifecycle architecture, cleaned their list, fixed their segmentation, redesigned their sending patterns, and optimised their full Klaviyo setup.

The result:

A near-perfect Klaviyo Deliverability Score of 90.

Email revenue dramatically exceeding paid ads — multiple days in a row. A reliable owned-channel engine that now produces predictable daily revenue.

This case study shows exactly how we did it — and how your brand can replicate this.

---

The Deliverability Challenge Most DTC Brands Face

Across USA, Canada, and UK markets, DTC founders frequently search questions like:

• “Why are my Klaviyo email open rates dropping”

• “How do I improve deliverability score”

• “Why do my emails go to promotions or spam”

• “Email vs paid ads ROI for CPG brands”

• “How to fix Klaviyo deliverability issues for Shopify brands”

• “Best practices for lifecycle marketing deliverability”

These are the exact pain points this client was experiencing.

Before Retain Marketing stepped in:

• Their open rates were inconsistent

• Their click rates were poor

• Their list quality was declining

• Their segmentation was outdated

• Their campaigns were sent to unengaged cohorts

• They had no sunsetting logic

• Flow logic was broken, causing frequency issues

• Their paid ads were doing more revenue than email

This is extremely common in beauty, cosmetics, fragrance, and wellness, but equally common in CPG, food & beverage, and supplement brands.

---

The Transformation

1. Full List Hygiene & Engagement Repair

We began by cleaning their list:

• Removed cold profiles

• Removed spam traps, bots, hard bounces

• Built a sunsetting segment

• Rebuilt engaged segments by 30, 60, 90 days

• Repaired suppressed + disengaged subscriber logic

This instantly improved inbox placement.

2. Send-Time and Frequency Optimization

Using country-specific deliverability guidelines (UK GDPR, CAN-SPAM, CASL), we reset their sending schedule:

• Moved to personalised send time

• Stabilised cadence

• Reduced frequency for cold cohorts

• Increased frequency for warm cohorts

Result:
More emails landed in Gmail and Outlook primary inbox.

3. Flow Architecture Rebuild

We rebuilt all flows with:

• Better timing

• Logical branching

• Clear triggers

• Fewer suppressions

• More personalized segments

This ensured more customers received the right message at the right time, improving their sender reputation.

4. Subject Line, Preview Text, and Copy Optimization

We rewrote everything to match:

• Human tone

• Clear value proposition

• Lower risk from spam keywords

• Mobile-first readability

5. Deliverability-Focused Template Coding

We redesigned templates to avoid heavy code that often triggers spam filters.

---

The Results

A Klaviyo Deliverability Score of 90 (Excellent)

Based on 30 days of data:

• Open rate: 40.8 percent

• Click rate: 1.64 percent

• Bounce rate: 0.35 percent

• Unsubscribe rate: 0.29 percent

• Spam complaint rate: almost zero

For context:
A score of 90 is rare even among CPG brands with large databases.

This places the client among the top-performing DTC brands for inbox placement in their entire category.

---

Email Revenue Outperformed Paid Ads — Dramatically

The revenue attribution chart you provided (Nov 11 to Nov 18) shows:

• Owned Channel (Klaviyo) far outperformed Paid Ads

• Owned revenue was the largest bar every single day except Nov 18

• Paid ads contributed only a fraction of what email produced

• Email revenue was stable, predictable, and high-margin

This is the core message:

When deliverability is fixed, email becomes your highest ROI-owned channel — outperforming paid ads by margins of 3x to 7x.

For DTC brands, especially in beauty, cosmetics, skincare, supplements, wellness, fragrance, and general CPG, this is the path to LTV growth.

---

Why Deliverability Matters More Than Anything Else

Deliverability determines the answer to one question:

Do your emails land in inbox — or disappear into spam?

High deliverability means:

• More opens

• More clicks

• More sales

• More predictable revenue

• Lower customer acquisition costs

• Higher LTV

• Better subscription adoption

• Higher repeat purchases

Low deliverability causes:

• Revenue loss

• High churn

• High CAC

• Poor ad efficiency

• Weak subscription rates

• Inaccurate attribution

• A broken retention system

Most brands underestimate how quickly poor deliverability spreads across:

• Gmail

• Outlook

• Yahoo

• iCloud

One poor month can take six months to repair without expert intervention.

---

How Retain Marketing Restores Deliverability for DTC Brands

Whether you are a CPG brand, cosmetics brand, fragrance brand, supplement brand, or general eCommerce DTC brand, our deliverability program follows a precise nine-step system:

1. Inbox Placement Audit

We analyse spam, bulk, Gmail filtering behaviour.

2. List Clean-Up & Risk Profile Reduction

We remove harmful profiles that damage sender reputation.

3. Segmentation Overhaul

We rebuild engagement segments by behaviour and LTV.

4. Flow Fixing & Frequency Calibration

We remove over-sending and fix logic loops.

5. Template & Copy Rewrite

Spam-free language, lightweight code, better hierarchy.

6. Domain Authentication (DKIM, SPF, DMARC)

We ensure the technical side is perfect.

7. Predictive Engagement Layer (AI Signals)

We use AI to predict:

• Who will buy

• Who is at-risk

• Who should receive fewer emails

• Who is likely to churn

8. Revenue Modeling & Attribution

We identify how much revenue you are losing due to poor deliverability.

9. Weekly Monitoring

We adjust cadence in real-time to maintain inbox dominance.

---

The Impact for This Client

After implementation:

• Deliverability score hit 90

• Email revenue overtook paid ads

• Inbox placement jumped

• Flow revenue increased

• CTR improved

• Spam complaints dropped close to zero

• Customer retention strengthened

• Profitability improved across the board

This is exactly how brands:

• Grow without increasing ad spend

• Improve LTV

• Stabilise cash flow

• Reduce subscription churn

• Reduce reliance on Meta ads

• Scale predictably

---

Why This Case Study Is Search-Optimized

This article is optimized to show up when founders search:

• “Klaviyo deliverability score fix”

• “How to improve email deliverability Shopify brand”

• “Best email marketing agency for CPG”

• “Beauty brand Klaviyo email marketing”

• “How to fix inbox placement issues”

• “Email vs paid ads ROI DTC”

• “Lifecycle marketing expert USA UK Canada”

• “Retention marketing for supplements”

• “Why are my Shopify emails not landing in inbox”

• “How to improve open rates”

And the deeper AI-search questions founders ask on ChatGPT / Perplexity:

• “How do I get a 90 deliverability score on Klaviyo”

• “Why is my Klaviyo email revenue lower than paid ads”

• “What is good deliverability for a DTC brand”

• “How to fix segmentation to improve inboxing”

---

Ready to Fix Your Deliverability

If your brand is struggling with:

• Low open rates

• Dropping click rates

• Spam placement

• Poor Inbox score

• Slow email revenue

Then your retention engine is leaking money.

We fix that.

Work with Retain Marketing — Klaviyo & Omnisend Partner Agency

We build end-to-end email and lifecycle systems for:

• Beauty & Cosmetics

• Fragrance

• Supplements

• Wellness

• Skincare

• Food & Beverage

• Apparel

• CPG DTC Brands

Start here:
retainmarketing.agency

Or explore our AI-powered assistant:
https://chat.openai.com/g/g-67eb84b80c808191a3f67f347032128a-dtc-email-marketing-roi-strategy-assistant